It is long, brown, slow and about the length of a thumbnail, and it was on the inside of the bedroom curtain this morning. When it flew, it buzzed. In October and November that description very often belongs to the western conifer seed bug, which is not the stink bug most people assume it is.
The western conifer seed bug is a dull brown true bug about 3/4 inch (19 mm) long, according to Penn State Extension, with a faint white zigzag across its back and flattened, leaf-like segments on its hind legs, which the shield-shaped brown marmorated stink bug lacks. It moves indoors in fall to overwinter and does not damage the house.
What is the one feature that identifies a western conifer seed bug?
The hind legs. Utah State University Extension describes flat, leaf-like projections on the hind legs, and Maine’s Department of Agriculture, Conservation and Forestry describes the same thing as thick, flattened tibia. The University of Wisconsin Insect Diagnostic Lab calls them distinctly dilated and compares them to bell-bottoms, which is the description people tend to remember.
This is the feature to check first because it survives every condition in which you will actually meet the insect: on a ceiling, in poor light, half behind a curtain rod, walking slowly away. The flattened plate is on the lower part of the back leg, and it is usually visible without getting close. A stink bug has no such plate.
The second feature is the zigzag. Maine describes a faint white zigzag stripe across the midpoint of the upper surface, and the Wisconsin lab describes a zigzag pattern on each wing that it likens to a lightning bolt. It is faint, as Maine says, and in a dim room it can disappear, which is why it comes second.
How big is it?
The published figures cluster tightly. Penn State gives adults as 3/4 inch (19 mm) long, and Maine gives about 3/4 inch (19 mm). Utah State gives a range of 5/8 to 3/4 inch, which is about 16 to 19 mm. Penn State gives the eggs as about 2 mm (0.08 inch), a little over 1/16 inch, which matters only if you find a row of them on a conifer needle in summer.
The antennae add to the impression of size. Maine notes that they are usually as long as the body, so the insect reads as longer than its body measurement when it is walking with them held forward.
Western conifer seed bug or stink bug?
This is the pair people confuse most often, and both of them arrive on the same walls in the same weeks. Penn State has brown marmorated stink bug adults searching for overwintering sites from September through October, and Utah State has the western conifer seed bug seeking indoor overwintering sites when cold fall weather begins in September and October.
The outline settles it before the legs do. Penn State describes the brown marmorated stink bug as shield shaped, almost as wide as it is long, and gives the adult as about 17 mm (0.66 inch) long. The Wisconsin lab describes the conifer seed bug as longer and more slender in appearance. Laid side by side they are easy to separate: one is a broad brown shield, the other is a narrow brown oblong with long antennae and wide back legs.
If the outline is ambiguous because the insect is on its side or partly hidden, use the stink bug’s own marks. Penn State tells readers to look for lighter bands on the antennae and patches of coppery or bluish metallic punctures. Then go back to the hind legs, which on the conifer seed bug carry the flattened plates the stink bug lacks.
Both insects produce a smell, which is why the two are confused even by people who have seen both. Maine notes that conifer seed bugs are often mistaken for stink bugs because they produce an unpleasant odor when alarmed, and Utah State describes that odor as piney. Smell is a poor way to identify either one, since it requires disturbing the insect first.
The stink bug guide covers the brown marmorated stink bug in more detail, including the other shield-shaped insects that come indoors.
Is it a leaf-footed bug?
It is a close relative, and in the West the confusion is real. Utah State notes that the western conifer seed bug is similar in appearance to the western leaf-footed bug and separates them by the absence of a thorn-like projection extending from the head. The leaf-footed bug has that spine; the conifer seed bug does not.
Seeing that projection on a live insect generally needs a clear side view or a photograph you can enlarge, and where the two species overlap it is the feature that has to be checked rather than assumed.
What happens when it flies?
It buzzes. Penn State notes that flying adults produce a loud buzz, and Maine describes the same buzzing sound in flight. For a lot of households this is the first sign anything is there at all, and together with the long brown body it is a useful clue.
When the wings open, the upper surface of the abdomen comes into view. Utah State describes it as yellow-orange with 5 black patches visible during flight, and Penn State describes alternating patches of yellow or light orange and black. You rarely see this on a resting insect, because the wings cover it.
Where did it come from, and why now?
The name gives most of it away. Utah State says the insects develop on pines, Douglas-firs and other conifers, feeding primarily on their seeds, and the Wisconsin lab says the species feeds on the seed cones of pines and other conifers. A house near pines or spruces is a house near its summer habitat.
It is also a long way from where it started. Penn State describes the species as native to temperate areas of the Pacific Coast of western North America, spreading eastward from the 1950s, and first found in Pennsylvania in 1992. Penn State gives it a single generation per year in North America.
The fall movement is about the winter. Penn State notes that adults move to protected places to overwinter and often become fall home invaders, with low numbers sometimes emerging indoors through the winter and larger numbers on warm days in fall and spring. The Wisconsin lab adds that, compared with the stink bug, they tend to invade in relatively low numbers. A handful on the upstairs windows is the normal pattern; a wall covered in brown shields is more likely the stink bug.
The fall timing it shares with lady beetles, boxelder bugs and cluster flies is covered in the windowsill post, and the slow gray flies that turn up on the same upstairs windows have their own walkthrough. If the insect on the sill is black with red or orange lines rather than brown, the boxelder bug guide is the place to check.
Does it do any damage?
The sources are unusually consistent. Penn State says adults do not generally bite people and are not considered a medical risk. Maine says they do not bite or sting and will not damage the structure of a house. In the trees, the Wisconsin lab notes that the insect does not seem to cause much, if any, harm, although Penn State records that feeding can cause serious seed losses in conifer seed orchards, which is a forestry concern rather than a household one.
There is one oddity worth knowing about. Maine notes occasional reported damage to PEX pipes, the plastic tubing sometimes used in plumbing and radiant heating systems. It is described as an exception, and if you have reason to think it applies, your local extension service is the right place to ask.
What a photograph will and will not settle
Photograph it where it sits, from the side if you can, so that both hind legs are in frame. The flattened plates read clearly in profile and almost disappear in a straight-down shot. Leave it on the wall or curtain, or coax it onto a sheet of paper and photograph it there. If the head is visible, a second shot of it is the one that settles the leaf-footed bug question.
When it is down to the conifer seed bug, a stink bug or a leaf-footed bug, a single clear photo in Bug Identifier returns a name, the other names it goes by, its scientific name and classification, and a description to check the match against. It also gives the insect’s role, which for this one is a nuisance indoors rather than a pest of the house. Each scan is kept in a dated collection, so the first one on the window in October and the one that wakes up on a warm afternoon in February sit in the same record.
To work from where you found something else entirely, start at what bug is this.
Sources
- Western Conifer Seed Bug, Penn State Extension
- Western Conifer Seed Bug, Utah State University Extension
- Western Conifer Seed Bug, Leptoglossus occidentalis, Maine Department of Agriculture, Conservation and Forestry
- Conifer Seed Bugs, University of Wisconsin Insect Diagnostic Lab
- Brown Marmorated Stink Bug, Penn State Extension